Is PetSmart or Petco Cheaper for Cats? A Complete Price Guide
PetSmart is generally cheaper than Petco for cat food and supplies, though prices vary by product and sales. Walmart and Chewy often beat both on price. For cat care services, costs differ by location.
Is PetSmart or Petco Cheaper for Cats? A Price Showdown
Generally, PetSmart has lower everyday prices on cat food and supplies than Petco. However, sales, coupons, and loyalty rewards can flip the comparison for specific items. For example, a bag of a popular cat food might cost $29.99 at PetSmart but $34.99 at Petco, while a litter brand could be cheaper at Petco during a promotion.
| Factor | Why It Matters | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| Cat food (dry) | Staple cost per pound; PetSmart often beats Petco on regular price. | $1–$3 per lb; varies by brand and size |
| Cat food (wet) | Can-style prices; Petco sometimes matches or undercuts with multi-buy deals. | $1–$2 per can; varies |
| Cat litter | Heavy item; PetSmart frequently has lower per-pound costs, but Petco's sales can compete. | $10–$20 per 20-lb bucket; varies |
| Toys and accessories | Margin-heavy; both stores mark up, but PetSmart's clearance sections are often deeper. | $5–$30; varies |
For the best price, check both stores' weekly ads and use their apps. If you're comparing for your cat's routine needs, PetSmart is usually the safer bet for everyday savings.
Real Customer Reviews: Is PetSmart or Petco Better for Your Cat?
Reddit threads and customer reviews frequently note that PetSmart seems to generally have lower prices than Petco, but many cat owners report that their specific cat food is actually cheaper at Petco. Prices for cat items were mostly the same in some comparisons, with the difference coming down to weekly deals and loyalty perks.
Beyond price, customers often mention store cleanliness, staff knowledge, and the stress level for cats. PetSmart's in-store vet clinics and grooming services are convenient, while Petco's focus on holistic products appeals to some owners. Neither store is universally "better"—it depends on your cat's needs and your budget.
If you're in the Rocklin area, you might also consider a cats-only clinic like ours for vet care, where the environment is designed to reduce feline stress.
PetSmart vs. Petco: Quality, Selection, and Services for Cat Owners
Price isn't the only factor. Here's how the two stores stack up on quality and services that matter for cat owners.
| Criterion | PetSmart | Petco |
|---|---|---|
| Product selection | Wide range of mainstream brands; strong private label | More natural/organic options; holistic focus |
| Cat food quality | Good variety, but fewer premium lines | Better for specialty diets (grain-free, limited ingredient) |
| Services | In-store vet clinics, grooming, training | Vet clinics in some locations, grooming, training |
| Loyalty program | Treats program: points on most purchases, occasional double-points | Vital Care: 20% off food and supplies with monthly fee |
| Price matching | Matches competitors' prices, including online | Matches select competitors, but not always online |
If you prioritize premium nutrition, Petco may justify slightly higher prices. For budget-friendly shopping with solid service, PetSmart is often the better choice.
Cheaper Alternatives: Walmart, Chewy, and Other Options for Cat Supplies
Walmart consistently offers the cheapest dry cat food cost per pound among major retailers, and Chewy often beats both PetSmart and Petco with subscription discounts and frequent sales. Target also competes on price for litter and treats.
| Factor | Why It Matters | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| Walmart | Low everyday prices, especially for dry food; no membership needed. | Often 10–20% less than PetSmart/Petco; varies |
| Chewy | Auto-ship saves 5–35% on recurring orders; wide selection. | Varies; often cheaper than brick-and-mortar |
| Target | Competitive on litter and treats; frequent promotions. | Varies; comparable to Walmart |
For Rocklin residents, Walmart and Target are close by, and Chewy delivers to your door. If you're comparing for your cat's routine needs, these alternatives can save you more than either pet store.
Directions to our cat veterinarian near me from Placer County Superior Court
Start at Placer County Superior Court and head to Cats Only Clinic at 1220 Sunset Blvd, Rocklin, CA 95765.
Cat Adoption vs. Purchase Costs at PetSmart and Petco
Both PetSmart and Petco host adoption events with local shelters, but they don't sell cats directly. Adoption fees vary widely, typically ranging from $50 to $150, and often include spaying/neutering, vaccinations, and a microchip. Buying a purebred cat from a breeder can cost hundreds to thousands of dollars.
| Factor | Why It Matters | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| Adoption fee | Includes initial vet care; cheaper than buying | $50–$150; varies |
| Breeder purchase | High cost, not via PetSmart/Petco | $500–$2,000+; varies |
Adoption is almost always the more affordable and ethical choice. If you adopt, you'll still need to budget for ongoing vet care—our clinic offers a free first exam for new clients to help you get started.
Money-Saving Tips: Loyalty Programs, Price Matching, and Coupons at PetSmart and Petco
Both stores run loyalty programs that can cut costs on cat food and supplies, but the exact savings vary by location and promotions. Here’s how to stretch your budget at either retailer.
| Strategy | How it works | Typical savings |
|---|---|---|
| Loyalty programs | Earn points or rewards on purchases; members may get exclusive deals and birthday offers. | Varies; often 5–10% back in points or equivalent |
| Price matching | Both stores may match a competitor’s price on identical items, but policies differ by location and require proof. | Up to the price difference |
| Coupons and promo codes | Check the store app, email newsletters, and weekly ads for discounts; stacking may be limited. | Often 10–20% off, but varies |
| Bulk buying | Larger bags or multi-packs usually lower the per-unit cost, especially for litter and dry food. | Can save 10–15% per unit |
| Subscribe & save | Auto-delivery options (online or in-store) may offer a discount on recurring orders. | Typically 5–10% off |
Before you pay full price, ask a store associate about current promotions or price-match policies. For everyday savings on cat care, our team can help you plan affordable wellness visits—see our Rocklin cat vet for details.
Sources
Also asked as
- Which store is cheaper for cat supplies?
- PetSmart vs Petco price comparison for cats
- Where can I save money on cat food?
Frequently asked questions
How much does a cat cost at Petco?
Petco doesn't sell cats directly; it hosts adoption events with local shelters. Adoption fees typically range from $50 to $150 and often include spaying/neutering, vaccinations, and a microchip.
What is the cheapest pet store?
Walmart generally has the lowest prices on dry cat food per pound, while Chewy often beats both PetSmart and Petco with subscription discounts. For everyday supplies, PetSmart tends to be cheaper than Petco.
How much do cats usually cost at PetSmart?
PetSmart also doesn't sell cats; it partners with shelters for adoptions. Adoption fees vary, usually $50–$150, and include initial vet care. Buying from a breeder costs significantly more.
Should I buy from Petco or PetSmart?
If you're looking for lower everyday prices, PetSmart is usually the better choice. If you prefer premium or natural cat food, Petco may be worth the extra cost. Check weekly ads and use loyalty programs to save at either store.
What store is more expensive, Petco or PetSmart?
Petco tends to be more expensive on many cat items, but not always. Sales and promotions can make Petco cheaper for specific products. Compare prices on your cat's regular food and litter to see which store wins for you.